CODART, Dutch and Flemish art in museums worldwide

Museum De Lakenhal Acquires Masterpiece Man with a Blind Eye by Master I.S.

Museum De Lakenhal has acquired Man with a Blind Eye, a painting by the mysterious seventeenth-century artist Master I.S., from a private collection. The work ranks among the finest pieces in the artist’s exceptionally rare oeuvre. The acquisition is all the more remarkable following the discovery of a monogram and a date during conservation. The newly uncovered monogram confirms the painting’s earlier stylistic attribution to Master I.S. Man with a Blind Eye will be on display at the museum from Tuesday 15 December 2026.

Master I.S., Man with a Blind Eye, 164[3], Museum De Lakenhal, Leiden

A Masterpiece with a Compelling Story

Master I.S. is one of the most enigmatic painters of the seventeenth century. The artist, who signed his works with the initials I.S., was active in the Netherlands, although he is also associated with Scandinavia and Eastern Europe. His oeuvre, moreover, displays similarities to the work of artists working in Leiden during the same period. Despite more than a century of art-historical research, the identity of this contemporary of Rembrandt remains unknown. Only an estimated 25 to 35 paintings by the artist are known, most of which are held in international and private collections.

Man with a Blind Eye is one of the most important works in this modest oeuvre, alongside major pieces in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna, the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts, and the Nationalmuseum in Stockholm. The portrait depicts an older man in three-quarter profile, with his damaged left eye turned prominently toward the viewer. His face is rendered with extraordinary precision, yet it is the artist’s treatment of the blind eye that is most striking.

Curator of old masters Janneke van Asperen: “Whereas seventeenth-century convention typically concealed physical imperfections or emphasized them as curiosities, Master I.S. took a different approach: he painted the eye with the same attentiveness and dignity as the rest of the face. Man with a Blind Eye is thus an exceptional painting that offers a fresh perspective on seventeenth-century attitudes toward humanity.”

Conservation of Man with a Blind Eye. Photo: Marco De Swart

Conservation Reveals Monogram and Date

To present the work to its best advantage, it is currently undergoing conservation treatment and being fitted with a new frame. During this process, some remarkable discoveries were made: beneath an old layer of overpainting, a monogram (I.S.) and a partially legible date emerged. This finding confirms the painting’s attribution to Master I.S., which had previously been proposed by the art historian Volker Manuth on stylistic grounds. The late Volker Manuth spent decades researching Master I.S. and was widely regarded as one of the foremost authorities on Rembrandt and his circle. His scholarship formed the basis for the recent exhibition Masterful Mystery – On Rembrandt’s Enigmatic Contemporary, and the acquisition of this painting serves as a lasting tribute to his dedication and scholarly work. Moreover, the newly uncovered date – believed to be 1643 – offers a crucial new benchmark for dating the artist’s broader oeuvre.

Conservation of Man with a Blind Eye, date and monogram visible in center-left. Photo: Marco De Swart

From Exhibition to Permanent Acquisition

Earlier this year, Museum De Lakenhal’s exhibition Masterful Mystery – On Rembrandt’s Enigmatic Contemporary brought together sixteen paintings by Master I.S. for the first time, attracting widespread public interest. The project was a collaboration with Serlachius Museums in Finland and leading specialists Volker Manuth, Marieke de Winkel (both of Radboud University) and David de Witt (Museum Rembrandthuis). The acquisition of Man with a Blind Eye – which made its public debut during the show – arose directly from this scholarship. The work is not only an exceptional addition to both Museum De Lakenhal and the Dutch national art collection, but also provides a vital reference point for future research. Man with a Blind Eye will be on display at the museum from Tuesday 15 December 2026.